The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Can frugality morph into a disease?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Can frugality morph into a disease?

    I have frequented this site for months now, and the thread that struck my interest the most was about the cheapest things people do. That thread summarized my life and it took me a while to decide to join this site and share my story with you all because I do not consider myself to be a "cheap" person but rather an intelligent consumer. I would like honest feedback on my situation from the savings advice community because loved ones have told me that they believe I have a disease.

    The way I live my life is to save every penny possible, purchasing only the most essential food and clothing with very little spent on entertainment or other items. I have pushed old friends away that criticized me for being too cheap. Its my belief that those who spend all their money and leave nothing for the future are the ones that need help. Yet, I dont criticize them. Anyways, read on and you decide.

    Right now I am posting this from my public library computer. I refuse to pay for the internet. I have composed this entire post on this same computer, each time I saved it to a floppy that I found on the sidewalk a few years back. I would never pay for a floppy or zip drive or whatever do-dad people are using these days. I arrived here on foot because I do not own an automobile. Depreciation is a waste of money. Car insurance is a bigger waste of money. Dont even get me started on gasoline. I own a bike that I was given as a gift 15 years ago. I would sell it but my office is a 20 min walk away and wasted time is wasted money, IMHO.

    My daily life includes walking to work with food I prepared up to a month before. I use a crock pot, that was also a gift several years back, to cook and freeze anything I cant eat within the next week. Most of the food I prepare is free. How? I have been known to "dumpster dive", or request food from establishments that are going to throw the food out anyways. I also visit shelters, food pantries, anywhere food is cheap or free. I then take as much as they will give me and I bring it home. My free time is spent either working for side money or dressing up as if I'm homeless and begging for food and money. Call this morally or ethically wrong but I do not indicate I'm homeless. I just dress in old shabby clothes and ask for money or food.

    Within the past decade alone I have shined shoes, drove taxi, shovel snow, plowed (using a coworkers truck when he was too tired to continue), delivered newspapers, everything landscaping or handyman, washed cars, pumped gas, sold merchandise and food on street corners (seperately), drove old people around, drove a limo, cleaned houses, cleaned toilets in commercial properties, collected cans, tutored middleschool and highschool students, I get paid to take surveys or give my opinion in focus groups, web design, advertised, surveyed people for their opinions, and have worked dozens of retail and other part time jobs.

    As one can tell I'm quite busy and have actually found it bothersome to put this document together. However, I feel it may be beneficial to myself and others to share this story with you all. I also have come to a point in my life where I think some elements to the way I'm living could be considered to not be in my best interest and I do not know if what I'm doing is really worth it. For example, is it wise to spend hours in the cold shoveling snow for $40 if it could mean getting ill and missing several days of work?

    After high shcool I decided not to attend college because it seemed very expensive and I wasnt able to obtain scholarships. Not wanting to put myself in massive debt and refusing to take a penny from my parents, I worked at an autobody shop during the day and by night was a bouncer at a local club. Every year since age 22 I have contributed a minimum of 50% of my net income to retirement. I have not spent more than 20% of my net income in any one year, and have lead a life at the poverty level. By my mid 20s I was working construction because it paid well. I lived with my parents until age 27 then moved into an apartment with old friends. I paid $200/month. The unusual part is that I still live there and I'm 39.

    Why haven't I moved? Money. Most adults my age pay more in property taxes than I pay to rent. I still share the place with three college students. I dont mind because they are more into studying than partying. I still work in construction. I moved up by working hard, getting promoted, and learning everything related to business and construction via the public library as well as any code books I could get my hands on. I now own a construction company with a business partner and the only vehicle I use is the company work truck. I sometimes bring it home but never have to pay for upkeep or gas.

    My income is six figures and the company has weathered the housing meltdown pretty well. No kids, no spouse, and currently no girlfriend. My parents left me their home and 2 of their investment properties. I sold all three due to the property taxes and upkeep that was killing any profit I would have made. I banked $1.2 million from the sales and turned to a family member to assist me in investing it wisely.

    Enough of the long narrative. Since most of what I have/own I obtained free, the following is a list that I have kept of things I have purchased with my own money in the last month:

    1/4/2010 - 1 quart of 1% milk for $1.59
    12/28/2009 - Weather related items - hat, two bags of sodium chloride, winter gloves (work gloves are different) Total of $19.39 with coupon for the hat and found the gloves on sale
    12/19/2009 - 1 loaf of bread, half dozen eggs, 1% milk for $3.16
    12/17/2009 - Coffee for myself, business partner, two top employees. I lost the receipt so I cannot legally expense - about $8.
    12/13/2009 - Food shopping - tuna, frozen dinners with coupons, fruit from reduced rack (orange, banana, lettuce), gallon of water bc water main break turned water brown at the apt. plus a few other essentials for $24.62
    12/9/2009 - Was feeling generous so I bought a few gifts for a few friends and family $108
    12/5/2009 - Used all my grocery coupons and tricks to get $80.xx worth of groceries for $9.59
    It seems during the holidays every business was giving out food. Milk is harder to come by.
    Total = $174.35

    A usual month is $50-$70, but the holidays got in the way. I plan to cut out all extra spending, not drink milk, eat only the food I have left over from the holidays and the crock pot for the rest of this month. One other detail is that I do not tell anyone of my friends or family what I make but rather lie to them about my profession and say I'm barely making it as a roofer. This way they do not expect lavish gifts and they understand why I live the way I do. I keep my close friends and family out of my work life completely.


    So that's a snapshot of my life. Again, my goal is to spend money only when necessary and save everything for the future. Has my frugality morphed into a disease? Considering I earn a good paycheck, have saved everything I have ever earned and still dumpster dive, some would say I have a disease. Those same people telling me that I have a disease are in their 40s and 50s with massive debt and little savings for retirement so I disregard their comments. Feel free to comment and ask questions. My time is up now on this computer. I will check back in a few days if you have questions. Thanks

  • #2
    Our retirement plans would go so much easier if I could count on 1.2 million in property from our parents. Having just sent them $2500 so they could pay rent and eat, I am not going to depend on your method there

    I like your frugality though! I think if it is a disease they don't need to make a vaccine for it.
    Last edited by KTP; 01-18-2010, 01:50 PM.

    Comment


    • #3
      I keep my close friends and family out of my work life completely.

      I personally think this is not such a good idea..for me the time spent with close friends and family is worth 1000 times more than the real 1000$ i saved in my account..but thats my opinion

      you will loose all friends..in this process
      Last edited by kn96373; 01-18-2010, 01:50 PM.

      Comment


      • #4
        (I'll compress all my thoughts into a single post, since it may be some time until you have responses)

        By "disease", it seems that you mean some form of mental/psychological disorder. I am by no means a doctor or psychologist (far from it), but in general terms, mental disorders are generally characterized as causing harm, distress, or negative effects to the individual, the people around him/her, or both. Only you can really evaluate if that is the case. Without trying to sound judgmental, you seem to be rather anti-social, which isn't really very healthy--we're social creatures, and building strong interpersonal relationships is beneficial to us.

        Regardless of all that, I only have one question (or rather, a series of related questions)... You do all this, live a hyper-frugal life, but to what end? Why do you feel the need to live the way you do? Is there a goal that you are working toward? If it's a comfortable retirement, what do you expect to do in retirement? It almost sounds like you wouldn't know how to make such a transition. Have you heard of the 'hoarder' mentality? Normally it's about things (everything is somehow "needed" or has some sort of sentimental value, so the person can't bear to part with anything). It seems you may be a bit like that, except with money... you can't bear to part with it, but don't necessarily have a reason to keep it.

        Do you have any hobbies that make you happy and that fulfill you? Do you ever take the opportunity to give charitable service? Those are both ways that you can productively spend your time and really take advantage of the time and opportunities that we have. You need to realize that with your current income, you don't need to do stuff on the side like shoveling snow or begging for food/money. Life isn't all about saving money or simply surviving from day to day. You need to enjoy yourself, enjoy life, enjoy the opportunities life presents, and enjoy the people around you. Not that people shouldn't save for the future (everyone should), but we shouldn't live for the future either, because that would be a wasted life in my opinion.

        In the end, if you are having concerns that there might be something wrong mentally or physically, the best thing you can do for yourself is to seek the appropriate medical/psychological attention.

        (If any of this has sounded offensive or condescending, I'm very sorry. I only mean to help you evaluate yourself and decide what is right for you)

        Comment


        • #5
          I think it is fair to say that most people would consider your lifestyle quite extreme, even bordering on obsessive. Dumpster diving for food, panhandling for money for someone with a 6-figure income certainly at least suggests the possibility of mental illness but I'm not a psychiatrist nor is anyone here as far as I know, so we certainly can't diagnose you with a "disease".

          Are you happy? Do you like the lifestyle you are living? Do you have a social life, friends, interests outside of work and saving money?

          The fact that you find it necessary to lie to your friends and family about your job also suggests there is a deeper problem here.

          If you came to me as a patient (I'm a physician), all I can say is that I would definitely urge you to seek counseling.
          Steve

          * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
          * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
          * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by bobbipper View Post
            Most of the food I prepare is free. How? I have been known to "dumpster dive", or request food from establishments that are going to throw the food out anyways. I also visit shelters, food pantries, anywhere food is cheap or free. I then take as much as they will give me and I bring it home.

            ...

            My income is six figures and the company has weathered the housing meltdown pretty well.
            I hope this is a joke, but if it isn't ...

            The bold portions are where I have a REAL problem --- and I do think you need to change your lifestyle. My wife & I volunteer at shelters & food-banks around the holidays and a LOT of those places are scrambling to meet the needs of the people they serve.

            You're making 6-figures, mooching off of donations from well-meaning people like myself, and depleting the resources available for those people who actually need them. I can't describe to you how mad I would be if I discoverd that you're frequenting one of the food shelters that we support in an effort to help those with incredibly unfortunate circumstances. I mean, I get upset when I see someone visit a food shelter & then go buy cigarettes - and your actions are just as bad ... maybe even worse!

            And all of this for what? Do you have a purpose for the money you're stashing? You mention saving for "the future" - but give no description of what that really means to you. I doubt that you have any intentions of helping others if you're so shamelessly taking advantage of resources designed for those that need help the most.

            Comment


            • #7
              re-reading it I actually now think this post was troll. I guess a good one since he got us to read and comment.

              I can't get over the fact that he gets 1.2 million dumped in his lap and still feels the need to do all of these things. His family investment help must suck big time. I could put 1.2 million into a mix of stocks and bonds and never have to work shoveling snow or begging for food or any of that for the rest of my life.

              Hence, got to be either the worst investor in history, a liar, or a troll.

              Comment


              • #8
                If not a troll, then obviously needs some counseling because it has gone too far. Taking food and handouts from people that truly need it is morally offensive, I think that is where the line is truly crossed in this storyline.

                And when does your future start? What would you plan on doing with the money if your mindset is this focused on not spending?

                Comment


                • #9
                  My free time is spent either working for side money or dressing up as if I'm homeless and begging for food and money. Call this morally or ethically wrong but I do not indicate I'm homeless. I just dress in old shabby clothes and ask for money or food.
                  If you make a 6 figure income, yes, I think this is morally and ethically wrong to manipulate the circumstances to appear if you are homeless and begging for money.

                  Good luck.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by KTP View Post
                    re-reading it I actually now think this post was troll. I guess a good one since he got us to read and comment.
                    I thought it was a troll post but responded anyway because I think it is an interesting post, even if it is fabricated.
                    Steve

                    * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
                    * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
                    * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by disneysteve View Post
                      I thought it was a troll post but responded anyway because I think it is an interesting post, even if it is fabricated.
                      Yes, but it did border on ridiculous. It would be like posting a poll on how many people separate their 2 ply toilet paper into single ply to get double the use in the frugal forum section.

                      Oh wait, there probably is that type of poll there.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Normally I say live and let live and whatever floats your boat and all that- but a millionaire making six figures dressing up like a homeless guy and taking food from shelters is morally wrong.

                        Your taking resources from those that truly need them and I would be more than I little upset if I knew someone like you got one of my handouts.

                        I vote for seeking counselling.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          KTP, there have been posters here that take toilet paper home from work so they don't have to buy it for home, so this is in the realm of possibility.

                          As far as the OP, do whatever floats your boat, but don't panhandle with millions in the bank, and don't take food away from someone who needs it. That is immoral. As for the rest, if you are happy, go for it.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by cptacek View Post
                            do whatever floats your boat, but don't panhandle with millions in the bank, and don't take food away from someone who needs it. That is immoral. As for the rest, if you are happy, go for it.
                            I have some issues with the "whatever floats your boat" advice. It may or may not apply here but if the OP truly suffers from some mental illness, saying, "if you are happy, go for it" really isn't appropriate. Mental illness takes a big toll on lots of people other than the patient, like the family, friends, housemates, co-workers, children, etc. Disease is disease, whether it be physical disease like diabetes or hypertension or mental disease like bipolar disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder or schizophrenia. It needs to be properly treated for everyone's benefit.

                            Just because the patient is happy the way he is doesn't mean his disease should be ignored.

                            By the way, OP. I'm very surprised that your public library computers accept floppy disks since they stopped putting floppy drives in computers quite a few years ago. Your library must have some older computers. Also, keep in mind that floppy disks don't last forever. They can only be rewritten a finite number of times and then start wearing out.
                            Steve

                            * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
                            * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
                            * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I feel like this one is a hoax.

                              But ... I worked with one of the ultimate penny pinchers. He bought store brand yogurt & ate exactly 1/3 of the yogurt at each meal ... actually levelled it out real nice so he could be sure he ate his 1/3 ration. When done he saved every empty yogut container in huge stacks in his office. He had hundreds & hundreds of them. He also ate a bologna sandwich every day for lunch: 2 pieces of bread & 1 piece of bologna; that's it. No mayo, no cheese, no frills. And drank tap water.

                              When he died all alone (surprised?), we found in his apartment what seemed to be every paper bag he had ever gotten at the grocery store, sitting open all over his apartment floors. You had to walk thru a maze of paper bags to go thru his place. When his time came, he had cancer throughout his whole body. He had been sick for a while & got more & more to where he could only whisper. He kept refusing to go to the doctor. Finally he caved, & the day he was actually diagnosed the Dr. gave him 2 or 3 three prescriptions & told him to get them filled right away ... but he still asked my mom to drive him by his apartment so he could get a coupon for the meds (she refused). He actually had 3 boys, & left them about $800K I think it was.

                              To each his own I guess.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X