The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

Pay of credit line/debt with savings… or not

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Pay of credit line/debt with savings… or not

    Hello,

    Dilemma in short, My wife and I have 25k in debt ((on a 200k line of credit, guaranteed about 2 or so points over prime forever) at about 7% interest. We also have about 40k in savings at 5% interst max.. We are both used to having a 3-6 month cushion in the bank. We pay the loan down as much as we can each month but It still seems we’re paying a elluva lot of interest

    My rational side say’s pay the loan off all or in part with savings (?); use aour monthly payment allotment to build up our savings again and, in a real pinch, hit up the line of credit line. My wife is very leery of having our nominal savings depleted. (Until 3 year neither of us have had a line of credit). But the most rudimentary math says we’d be way ahead by paying it off. (Aprox. Math says were losing 2 %)


    Other extraneous details, pertinent or not; our line of credit has no collateral backing it. Our So. Cal. house and 3 cars are completely paid for. I have about 7 k in the stock market. We have an impeccable credit rating. We also have no revolving credit card balance.

    We’re both in our mid 40’s with a healthy 3 yr. old .I’m self employed (boom and bust). My wife works part time at my families’ biz. -And last but not least, grandma has established a college fund for our son.

    We live a modest lifestyle but are comfortable. I have high hopes for the future of my biz, but who knows. My wife has very marketable skills.

    So the questions are:

    1) Is there any reason at all for not to pay of our debt with are savings (given our healthy line of credit at it’s reasonable rate for that rainy day (?))

    2) If we were to pay the whole loan of, would we essentially close our credit line?

    3) Any merit to paying most of it off while keeping a modest balance?

    4) Should the for mentioned be the right strategy, should we pay of al the debt, then borrow once a month and pay it of in full every month?

    5) Are there some tax disincentives for doing any of this?

    6) Are we likely to get hit with some early payment fee (anything standard)


    For me I just hate having the debt hanging over us like a cloud, effectively loosing money every month (gain 5% on savings and pay 7% on the loan), just for the piece of mind of having savings, who needs it if you have a good credit line? (we dip into it for a month once in awhile)

    All knowledgable advice is appreciated!! I must be missing something.

    Thanks in advance,

    Croak
    Last edited by Peter; 08-26-2007, 12:41 AM.

  • #2
    Originally posted by Peter View Post
    1) Is there any reason at all for not to pay of our debt with are savings
    No

    After you pay it off you will still have 15k left which is certainly enough for most emergencies. And the 2% differance will save you about $40 a month.

    Sure that big wad of cash in the bank may give you piece of mind, but it is a false sense of security imho.

    Comment


    • #3
      I would pay it off.

      Comment


      • #4
        Pay it off! Right now you are loosing money.

        Once it is paid off, you can start to build up your saving again.

        Comment


        • #5
          Although you have a house and 3 cars paid for, $25,000 is still ALOT of debt. My advice is to get rid of that $25k debt asap while you have the money saved up then you and your wife could continue to save up as much money as you want and be free of debt.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Peter View Post
            For me I just hate having the debt hanging over us like a cloud, effectively loosing money every month (gain 5% on savings and pay 7% on the loan), just for the piece of mind of having savings, who needs it if you have a good credit line? (we dip into it for a month once in awhile)
            After you gain 5% on your savings, that interest is taxed, so the effective rate is lower depending on your tax bracket.

            You didn't mention any tax advantaged retirement accounts! Roth IRA? SEP-IRA?

            If the money was earning more than 5% and the earnings weren't taxed (IRA) then it might make some sense to keep the debt & invest the money, but at those rates it doesn't make sense.

            Comment


            • #7
              I'm with Autoxer--what about retirement savings? If you're in your mid forties, I hope you have some. If not, I'd make that a priority right away.

              The other question I have is, how did you accumulate the debt? I'd be worried about paying it off if you might just rack it up again. If it were me, I'd pay it off and then close it and build up my savings as quickly as possible.

              Comment


              • #8
                yes you should pay it off.

                What your wife is afraid of, is a psichological issue we all have: she is afraid that after paying the loan the money surplus would not end up in savings or investments.

                If you feel you can overcome that limitation then go for the logical move: pay off debt, and once you get debt free allocate the surplus in savings and investment.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Pay off the debt first. W

                  Also, why do you have more then 3 - 6 months of expenses in a low return savings account?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I would say payoff the debt, but do not over extend yourself.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      I would pay off the debt, but keep the credit line open. That would serve as your "emergency fund" until you can up your savings to a number you and your wife are happy with. Once you have that, if the credit line is costing you something, you could close it, but if it doesn't cost you anything, you might as well keep it open.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Pay it off. I agree with your logic. I am a woman, but very logical. I think your wife is more emotional about the money. It is purely psychological. There is no reason to leave that 25K debt when you've got 40K in the bank. You'll still have 15K and be able to add to it as much as you want to. I personally am quite debt adverse, and do everything in my power to pay off any debt I incur as quickly as possible.

                        Comment


                        • #13

                          I'd have that credit line paid by the end of the week.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I agree, pay it off as soon as possible then make that payment back into your savings account.

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X