The Saving Advice Forums - A classic personal finance community.

"You deserve it".

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • "You deserve it".

    Each time I see an advertisement that uses words "you deserve" something, or a credit mailer to that effect, I keep thinking, "how do they know I deserve it? They don't even know me?"

    It seems effective though, because I think a lot of people get into financial problems because they believe they deserve, and thus going without something they deserve is not fair, so they should get, even if it means defaulting on loans down the line. And this is more common when it comes to things like having a house, or what neighbourhood you can afford to live in, or what car they drive. There is a disconnect between what you are getting in the marketplace and what you deserve. Therefore, it is often viewed by people as not their fault. The way they see it, they are struggling to keep the basic life they deserve. This believe is what caused the housing crisis, the credit card crisis and now the student loan problems.

    How people arrive at what is basic and necessary, is a mystery.

    I was once in a forum discussion where the woman argued that yes, there is no choice but to stay with a husband that beats her because if she lived on her own, she could only afford an apartment and doing that to a child is wrong. I was thinking she is out of her freaking mind! But to her, not having a yard was more unacceptable than being beaten. She made it sound that growing up in an apartment is the worst thing that can happen to a child and there is no way she would ever do that to her baby. Baby deserves a house and a yard, period.
    (Ok, I think I got a little bit off topic here -- whenever I remember that discussion, my blood is boiling. )


    To me, who lives in an apartment with a wonderful loving husband, what baby deserves is a stress-free environment and a feeling that home(even if it is an apartment) is a place where you feel loved, relaxed(emotionally), at peace and secure. To me, not giving that to your baby is horrible and will no doubt affect his development and personality.

    Would I love a yard? Very much so, but we could not afford a yard in NYC without foregoing any savings and all retirement, and that does not seem like a responsible choice. But I know of people with less than half our income who bought a house, and now, years later are approaching bancruptsy and can no longer supplement staying in this house by using credit feel angry and feel they are victims. Their family deserves this house. They just don't see past it. When it should have been obvious from day 1 that you can't afford a house almost 10x your income (and taxes and maintenance on said house). But they feel they are loosing it because things just cost too much -- taxes, daycare, gasoline, everything... and it is the fault of the entities that charge that much, and, of course, the bank. Life should be priced in such a way so that the house would be affordable to regular people like them, or regular income.

    But anyway, how do we really know what we deserve? And who can be objective in making such a determination about themselves?
    Last edited by Nika; 03-06-2012, 02:20 PM.

  • #2
    I've noticed by reading forums and blogs that a lot of people use the "I deserve it" as justification of spending money on things they can't afford. I tend to think about it as I deserve to have a financially secure future, which doesn't involve endless wasted money.

    Comment


    • #3
      It's pretty much all about justification.

      I think pretty much everybody deserves to live in relative safety, that every child deserves an education through high school and to live in a home free of violence and fear, and that everybody deserves basic rights like freedom and the opportunity to legally provide for themselves in one way or another.

      Comment


      • #4
        Oh lordy I work with the "I deserve it people/generation" . Honestly now they just amuse me most of the time, you can't fix them, you can just be happy in your own little world.

        My favorite is the I deserve it 20 something that I work with that just today was buying a $10.00 "item" from the family planning aisle while she can't figure out how to pay her past due $800 dollar electric bill.

        bb

        Comment


        • #5
          What you "deserve" is irrelevant, what you can afford is all that should matter. Otherwise, you're just shooting yourself in the foot.

          Comment


          • #6
            I agree with the OP. Every time I hear that phrase it is selling something and I think the same thing. Just a blatant ploy to separate the weak from their cash.

            Comment


            • #7
              My favorite is the I deserve it 20 something that I work with that just today was buying a $10.00 "item" from the family planning aisle while she can't figure out how to pay her past due $800 dollar electric bill.
              That actually is mighty responsible of her (I'm only guessing what the item is). Having babies is way more expensive and is not a good idea when you can't even cover current bills.
              Remaining a virgin until your 401k is fully funded is not a viable plan for everyone.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Nika View Post
                That actually is mighty responsible of her (I'm only guessing what the item is). Having babies is way more expensive and is not a good idea when you can't even cover current bills.
                Remaining a virgin until your 401k is fully funded is not a viable plan for everyone.
                Umm if it were contraceptive items no problem, but the "family planning" aisles have expanded quite a bit recently in retail stores, soooooooo it was something else.

                ff

                Comment


                • #9
                  am i the only one thinking handcuffs right now?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    So what did she buy? I have no idea what is in the family planning aisle.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by frugalfarmwife View Post
                      Umm if it were contraceptive items no problem, but the "family planning" aisles have expanded quite a bit recently in retail stores, soooooooo it was something else.

                      ff
                      We must know.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by ShawnaC123 View Post
                        So what did she buy? I have no idea what is in the family planning aisle.
                        Originally posted by Redraidernurse View Post
                        We must know.
                        I'm assuming it was something to "enhance" the experience.
                        Steve

                        * Despite the high cost of living, it remains very popular.
                        * Why should I pay for my daughter's education when she already knows everything?
                        * There are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          You "deserve' whatever you can afford to pay for from whatever you earned. If i can afford to buy a Mustang GTO because i worked hard and saved the money, then i really do deserve it. You deserve to enjoy the fruits of your labor. And, you should spend your money in a way that is pleasing to you and who cares what someone else thinks. Someone might think buying a Mustang is "dumb" but i might think getting granite countertops is equally dumb. Or not. It is YOUR money, do with it as you wish.

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X